Lutron vs Hunter Douglas vs Somfy shades
Lutron publishes the most hard numbers: under 35 dBA at 3 feet, hem bars aligned within 1/8 inch, an 8-year limited warranty, and about $800 to $2,200 per shade installed. Hunter Douglas PowerView runs about $600 to $1,400 per window through dealers. Somfy makes motors used inside many shade brands, at about $400 to $1,500 per window.
Three different kinds of company
The three names are often compared as if they made the same thing. They do not.
Lutron makes complete shades and the controls that run them. It has four shade lines: Serena (wire-free, for DIY or professional installation), Triathlon (professional wire-free shades for retrofits), Sivoia (the broad custom line) and Palladiom (the top line, with exposed metal hardware). It sells through sales reps and installers. Its site shows price as dollar symbols, not numbers.
Hunter Douglas makes complete window treatments of many types. Its roller family includes Designer Roller, Designer Screen and Alustra Architectural roller shades, motorized under the PowerView name. It sells through authorized dealers and publishes no prices.
Somfy makes motors and controls. As one national guide puts it, "Somfy motors power shades sold under dozens of other brands." A Somfy shade is a shade built by a fabricator around a Somfy motor. The tube, brackets, fabric and workmanship come from that fabricator.
What each one publishes, side by side
| Lutron | Hunter Douglas | Somfy | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Makes | Shades and controls | Window treatments | Motors and controls |
| Published noise | Under 35 dBA at 3 ft (Palladiom, Sivoia Roller 64); under 44 dBA (Sivoia Roller 20, Triathlon Select) | No figure on the pages we read | 42 dB (Sonesse Ultra 30 WireFree) |
| Published sizes | Palladiom wired: 20 to 144 in wide, 24 to 168 in high. Sivoia: 20 in to 20 ft wide | No limits on the pages we read | Set by the shade maker |
| Hem bar alignment | Within 1/8 in across shades | No figure published | No figure published |
| Warranty | 8-year limited | Not confirmed on the pages we read | 5 years on the motor |
| Power | Low-voltage wired, or D-cell wire-free | Battery or plug-in; low-voltage wiring for PowerView+ | Wire-free lithium, or wired |
| Battery life | 3 to 5 years (Palladiom, Triathlon); 2 years (Triathlon Select) | About once a year, per a help-center line we saw only as a search excerpt | No verified figure |
| Smart home | Own radio system; works with its Caséta, RadioRA 3 and HomeWorks QSX controls | PowerView Gen 3 supports Matter (Apple, Google, Alexa) | RTS is one-way; newer Z-Wave and io-homecontrol motors |
| Sold through | Sales reps and installers | Authorized dealers | Dealers and shade fabricators |
| Installed price | $800–2,200 per shade | $600–1,400 per window | $400–900 entry, $700–1,500 mid-market |
A blank in the table does not mean a product is poor. It means the maker does not put that number on a public page we could read. Each noise figure is the maker's own measurement, and the motors differ in size, so the figures are not a lab comparison.
Price ranges from public sources
None of the three publishes a dollar price. The installed ranges in the table come from a national home automation guide. One South Florida dealer, Exotic Shades, publishes a list that puts two of the brands side by side on the same 72 by 84 inch shade:
- Somfy wire-free: about $933
- Somfy wired: about $1,133
- Lutron Triathlon (wire-free): about $1,293
- Lutron Sivoia QS wired: about $2,287
That dealer states that "Lutron is sold at Lutron's list price (MSRP), installation and programming included." We found no comparable published list for Hunter Douglas. The cost guide shows what these per-shade prices add up to across a whole house.
Who each brand tends to suit
- Lutron suits an owner who wants noise and alignment numbers in writing, or whose house already runs on Lutron lighting control. It is the most expensive of the three in the public ranges.
- Hunter Douglas suits an owner who wants a wide fabric choice (its Designer Roller page lists more than 350 options), several shade styles from one maker, and a local dealer. PowerView Gen 3 connects to Apple, Google and Amazon systems through Matter. It publishes fewer performance numbers.
- Somfy suits an owner who picks the shade maker first. The motor is common and widely supported, and the result depends on who builds the shade around it. Ask which Somfy protocol is quoted: RTS is one-way, so the motor cannot report its position back to the system.
No one of the three is right for every house. The hardwired vs battery guide covers the power choice.
What the published specs leave out
Spec pages describe the motor. They say little about the parts an owner sees every day: how the roll is hidden, how the fabric hangs, how hem bars line up across a row of windows, and how clean the installation is. Those depend on the system chosen (pocket, fascia or open roll, shown on the systems page) and on the installer.
When comparing quotes, ask each seller for the same five things in writing: the noise figure for the exact motor, the alignment tolerance, the warranty on motor and fabric separately, the power type per window, and what the price includes.
Mode Shades is not a dealer for Lutron, Hunter Douglas or Somfy. This page reports what each company publishes, with the sources listed below. For how our own shades are priced, see pricing.
Questions owners ask
Hunter Douglas PowerView vs. Lutron: which is better and why?
Neither wins on every count. Lutron publishes noise, alignment and warranty figures and costs more: about $800 to $2,200 per shade against $600 to $1,400 per window for PowerView. Hunter Douglas offers more shade styles and Matter support.
Is the shade's motor loud?
Lutron publishes under 35 dBA at 3 feet for its quietest roller lines and under 44 dBA for smaller ones. Somfy lists 42 dB for one wire-free motor. We found no published figure for Hunter Douglas.
How are motorized shades powered?
By low-voltage wire, by a plug-in power supply, or by batteries. Lutron wire-free shades use D-cells. Hunter Douglas lists battery and plug-in supplies and requires low-voltage wiring for PowerView+.
How long do the motors last?
Makers publish warranties, not lifespans: 8 years limited from Lutron, 5 years on the Somfy motor we checked. One franchise guide estimates 10 to 15 years for quality motors.
Can these integrate with my existing smart home setup?
Usually. Lutron shades work with Lutron's own control systems. PowerView Gen 3 supports Matter and has Control4 and Crestron drivers. The control page explains keypads, phone, voice and schedules.